Breathtaking Ignorance


Hillary Clinton, fresh from her recent triumphs in Middle East diplomacy, took time to speak about economic issues at a New York gathering last night. She was speaking to supporters of her husbands foundation, the Clinton Global Initiative. I didn’t catch the title of her speech, but I think it was, “When are productive people going to do something useful like us politicians?”

Hillary said:

 

“There are rich people everywhere and yet they do not contribute to the growth of their own countries….

“They don’t invest in public schools, in public hospitals, in other kinds of development internally…

This is breathtaking economic ignorance, exactly like the French Atlas Shrugs story. This is Marxist, class envy nonsense. Could she actually believe that economic growth in a country is a gift from politicians? Could she believe that roads, bridges and hospitals come into existence as noble contributions from politicians who care? Does she not know where the money comes from?

I have a very low opinion of politicians, but I am still shocked by the cluelessness of these statements. These politicians who want to control your life have no idea how the world works. They represent a danger to your liberty and your prosperity.

Demagogues, Debt, and Atlas Shrugging

from The People’s Cube

Obama’s pre-election story is that taxing the rich is the key to funding the government and reducing the debt. Even his greatly expanded government will be financed by the rich paying their fair share.

This story is for people who do not understand anything at all about current government spending and the staggering size of our debt. Obama’s story is for uninformed voters. The question is, do the uninformed represent a majority yet?

Lying about the revenue available from taxing “the rich” may get votes, but it won’t change reality. Do the math. There is not remotely, in your wildest dreams, enough money to cover the spending of this government with increased taxes on top earners. The math has been explained many places, including here, and here, and here.

Obama’s proposed ‘tax the rich’ plan will solve about 5% of our deficit problem. And that assumes that productive people will not change their behavior in response to higher taxes, an unlikely assumption. Mike Flynn has just written a good summary of the absurdity of the plan. Others have shown that even if you take all the income from the top 1%, you can only finance this bloated government for a few months. And then what? The golden geese will be dead. Where would you get eggs next year?

France is going to learn this lesson ahead of us. France just elected a Socialist President who rode the class envy train to power. He is promising to tax top earners at 75%. Socialists have the delusion that you can take most of the product of someone’s labor and the person will keep working just as hard. Reality has never worked that way and never will.

Now, France’s richest businessman, Bernard Arnault, is leaving the country. As Daniel Greenfield reports, This Atlas is Shrugging. Arnault, the head of Louis Vuitton, employs 100,000 people in France and around the world. Many other people of substance are fleeing France. The French “Liberation” newspaper reported Arnault’s departure with this headline: “Get lost, rich bastard!”

Yes, you golden geese, you get the hell out. And Liberation people, talk to me in a year or two about how your socialist delusion works out for you. I already know how it works out because this is an old movie with a tragic ending. Reality always bats last.

Another aspect of overwhelming debt that is not discussed often enough is the close relationship between debt and national security. When Admiral Michael Mullen was chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, a reporter asked him to name the most significant threat to U.S. national security. His response was, “Our debt”.

On Monday, speaking to a panel of former members of Congress, Admiral Mullen elaborated on the dire implications of America’s fiscal path to our national security:

“A nation with our current levels of unsustainable debt, being this far out of fiscal balance, cannot hope to sustain for very long its superiority from a military perspective, or its influence in world affairs. That was not intended as a partisan statement then, and it has no partisan meaning now. I was using our growing and unsustainable debt as shorthand for the abundant disorder in our fiscal house, brought upon us, by ourselves, by our own doing. While much has been said since then, little has changed. In fact, I would argue that the mere passage of time, combined with a lack of solutions in the interim, has compounded the problem, as our debt increases seemingly exponentially, and solutions that require compromise seem a figment of the imagination.”

Note to Harry Reid…

So Mitt Romney doesn’t pay his fair share. In fact, Harry Reid, you have secret information that he doesn’t pay income tax at all. That’s what you said. And for sure, Mitt’s a selfish guy who doesn’t care about helping others. Right?

Apologies would be welcome, but we won’t hold our breath.

Romney release much additional tax info today and the highlights are these:

*The Romneys paid almost two million in income tax this year (3 million last year)

*They paid an average of 20.20% of their income to income tax over the last 20 years.

* Last year they donated 30% of their income to charity – over 4 million dollars.

* Over 20 years, the average share of their income that went to taxes and charity was over 38% of their income.

Check out Obama and Bidens history of charitable donations. It was often way up there in the 1 to 3 percent range. They sincerely care.

Update Harry Reids response to the egg on his face: “He’s hiding something. He’s hiding something.” No surprise Harry. We wouldn’t expect any integrity from you.

Aside

Today’s links…

Obama’s record. Great summary. How can anyone want more of this?

Please, Mitt. Change your strategy to win independent voters.

A newspaper series – The Obama You Don’t Know

Three great columns from Thomas Sowell – If you can only read one, make it this one – “The Fallacy of Redistribution”. Second, Can Republicans Talk? and Some Truth About Taxes, which includes this quote from John Kennedy:

“It is a paradoxical truth that tax rates are too high and tax revenues are too low and the soundest way to raise the revenues in the long run is to cut the rates now.”

Comedy Gold – Charlie Rangel lectures Mitt on paying a fair share of tax. Will Timmy Gaitner speak up next?

Aside

Poetic Justice-

Property Properly Covered

In Iran, a cleric was beaten by a woman he had passed on the street.

“Hojatoleslam Ali Beheshti said he encountered the woman in the street while on his way to the mosque in the town of Shahmirzad, and asked her to cover herself up, to which she replied “you, cover your eyes,” according to Mehr. The cleric repeated his warning, which he said prompted her to insult and push him.

“I fell on my back on the floor,” Beheshti said in the report. “I don’t know what happened after that, all I could feel was the kicks of this woman who was insulting me and attacking me.”

========
In Pakistan, an Islamist flamboyantly burned an American flag. He died of smoke inhalation. So sad.

Aside

On Working with Grizzlies…

I wrote earlier about Libya and Ambassador Stevens. It turns out that Stevens had gone secretly into Libya during the overthrow of Gaddafi. He was working with the rebels; the Grizzly’s, to use my earlier analogy. He thought they were his friends and would appreciate his help.

Caroline Glick elaborates in a good column on the naiveté of U.S. policy. A taste:

But did he understand the forces he was unleashing? Stevens arrived in Benghazi at an early phase of US involvement in the rebellion against Gaddafi, a former US foe who had been neutered since 2004. But even then it was clear that the rebels with whom he worked included jihadist fighters associated with al-Qaida. Their significance became obvious when just after the regime fell in November 2011, rebel forces foisted the flag of al-Qaida over the courthouse in Benghazi.Did Stevens understand what this meant?

via Column One: The reign of imaginat… JPost – Opinion -.

Aside

Quotes For Today-

Alexis de Tocqueville was a French political philosopher and historian, best known for his two volumes, Democracy in America, published in 1835 and 1840. Reading his books today makes him seem like a prophet, but he simply understood that ideas have consequence. He understood the American political experiment and he understood how it could go wrong. Here are some quotes that seem especially relevant today:

The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public’s money.

A democratic government is the only one in which those who vote for a tax can escape the obligation to pay it.

Democracy and socialism have nothing in common but one word, equality. But notice the difference: while democracy seeks equality in liberty, socialism seeks equality in restraint and servitude.

Americans are so enamored of equality that they would rather be equal in slavery than unequal in freedom.

In the United States, the majority undertakes to supply a multitude of ready-made opinions for the use of individuals, who are thus relieved from the necessity of forming opinions of their own.

Selling Lies

Politicians often sell lies. That’s nothing new. But rather than becoming accustomed to it, I am increasingly angered by it. There was massive lying about Obamacare, constant lying about who pays “their fair share” of the cost of government, lying about the debt crisis, lying about how serious they are about truly dealing with it, lying about the real unemployment rate, etc.. We deserve better from this disgusting group of people whom we mysteriously call “leaders”.

For brazen, ‘in your face’, lying, the current attempt by the Obama Administration to claim that the Libyan violence was “not a reaction to U.S. policy or 9-11″ is hard to beat. U.N. Ambassador, Susan Rice, said yesterday that the Libyan military assault was “spontaneous” and “not a premeditated assault”.

Libyan President Mohammed el-Megarif said,

“The idea that this criminal and cowardly act was a spontaneous protest that just spun out of control is completely unfounded and preposterous.”… [There is] “no doubt that this was preplanned, predetermined.”

Senator John McCain said,

“Most people don’t bring rocket-propelled grenades and heavy weapons to a demonstration,” he said. “That was an act of terror. And for anyone to disagree with that fundamental fact I think is really ignorant of the facts.”

A guard from the Libyan Embassy just reported that there was no protest at the Embassy on 9-11 until the 150 people making the military assault stormed onto the scene.

=============

One aspect of delusional foreign policy can be illustrated with the story of Grizzly Man, Timothy Treadwell. Timothy went to live with grizzlies in Alaska and to be their friend. Timothy said that he understood grizzlies and they understood him, and they were buddies. It was a sweet idea, like in second grade when you send a note saying, “I like you, do you like me”, and you just know you are going to get a reply, “Yes, I do”. Sing Kumbaya.

Timothy was killed and eaten by the grizzlies.